There was some concern expressed that our club's plan to assign extra ballast to drivers who drive in an unsafe manner will cause the slow drivers to be even less competitive with the fast drivers than they already are. But his view assumes that the slow drivers are unsafe and that fast drivers are safer. The fact is that the safe, slow drivers will be at no more of a disadvantage to the safe, fast drivers than they are under a system that does not penalize unsafe driving. In fact, the slow, safe driver may find a fast driver will have less of an advantage if his speed was gained by driving in a risky manner. The unsafe fast driver will either have to slow down or he will be slowed down my the additional ballast that he will acquire and keep until he does slow down.
What about the unsafe, slow driver. Here again another assumption is made. That is, that the unsafe, slow driver will not alter his driving style to avoid getting extra ballast. One would think that if he drives more carefully his lap times will increase, but this may not be necessarily so. If you look at an unsafe slow driver's average lap times for a race they may be something like 1:20, even though he was turning many of his laps in the 1:17 to 1:18 range. The off track excursions and the spins add time to his overall average. If he avoids those time consuming errors by lapping at a 1:18 to 1:20 pace then he will actually finish the race in less time than when he was trying to drive at a 1:16 pace and failing. And how do you factor into the lap times the races that he fails to finish because of his unsafe driving? Finishing races is definitely more competitive than not finishing at all. Also, I think that more consistent driving will eventually make the slow driver better in the long term.
I believe the system will only fail for those who see LFS as a game that can only be enjoyed if the player drivers full speed at all times. Anyone who has done real racing knows that this attitude does not work well in real life racing and that it is knowing that your actions will have consequences that adds the spice to the experience.