Metro is growing on me, obviously it's ideal for tablets but I really enjoy using it with a plain old mouse, everything is laid out exactly the way I want with my apps all grouped together and easily visible, it seems to me that people just don't like change.
I also completely disagree that Microsoft have lost the battle, Even Windows RT has massive advantages, running proper Windows 8 on a tablet is 1000x better than running a phone OS. It just needs time to mature and get the proper hardware out for it. Why would you get an android tablet (or ipad), with all it's restrictions, when you could basically get a PC?