Hey, I just wanted to pop in to say I was playing with the updated layout editor today.
I have mixed feedback. I will start with negatives so I can end on positives:-
# Negatives
## A. Fine tuning the height of objects is problematic
Why:
1. When an object is placed with o key, the X, Y and Z controls are not available.
2. Pressing PgUp, PgDown causes the object to deselect and create a new object unexpectedly. You then need to delete the other object.
## B. Selection States are confusing
Why:
When an object is placed with o, it is highlighted as though it is selected, however the move controls are not activated. The movement controls only appear when you click the object, which changes the selection color..?
## C. Losing selection when pressing space is not favorable
Why:
In the new editor, the screen can be crowded with 'Selection hints'. A creator like myself who wants to edit a layout will press Space just to see how the layout looks.
Before hand, when you pressed space again, your selection would be kept and you could resume. Now you cannot and it consumes time to get your selection back again.
Fixes:
1. Unless you can explain a tangible benefit why objects are no longer selected when placed, I suggest undoing this change, and automatically selecting the object when it is placed, like before.
2. Do not forget selections when pressing space - We use this just to see our layout without the visual clutter briefly - not to stop editing.
Okay, that's all my criticism.
# Positives
## The new selection boxes are good.
Keep them because before it could get really confusing to know what you had selected when there are just blue dots and often you would select the wrong thing without knowing.
## The keyboard shortcuts are good
I appreciate being able to raise and lower objects with pgup/pgdown.
Ctrl Z + Y is greatly appreciated too.
I think I'll keep an old copy of LFS around for layout editing now, because the object selection thing is actually a show stopper for someone like me as it significantly increases the amount of fiddling required to get objects into the right position. I really hope you can do something about that.
Have a good one,
Tommer