If someone starts in GT Amateur League 2010,and have no MoE/IGTC races,and in the middle of the GT Amateur League 2010 season,driver have debut in MoE/IGTC,can he continue GT Amateur League 2010 season or not.
I would like this,and would also like that teams who raced in season one have numbers from season one general standings (example,SCP finished first season on 6th place,in season 2010 they would be #6 Serbian Chromed Pistons).
We're not really commenting on what will/won't be in the series at the present time as we're still discussing it internally, but I thought I'd say some words on the subject of the following:
Personally, [and I would think I speak on behalf of NDR here] I want to see big grids full of the sort of people this series was intended for. The problem isn't [we hope :P] the big grids, but who is this series intended for - does the fact that a driver competed in an IGTC Race mean that he can't race in this?
Consider the following:
In the IGTC there is a good mix of big, well established teams aswell as some smaller, maybe national teams. Take an example of a smaller team with 5 members, and a much bigger team such as Sonicrealms. [sorry to single you out here guys!] Say you needed 4 members for one of the races in the IGTC, and one of the guys from the smaller team was ill or whatever. This means that the other person in that team, even if they were fairly new to LFS/never done a major league race before would be drafted in. However, in a team like SR, that wouldn't matter as they have dozens of superb drivers. Thus, we have a situation where a person from the smaller team, who we'd love to have in the GTAL, now cannot race as they've participated in an IGTC race. Furthermore, it might be that Sonicrealms have a new, up-and-coming driver who they want to give some Endurance Race Experience to, so they put him in an IGTC team. This is the kind of person we'd like to have, but again that person now cannot participate in this series.
Where do we draw the line?
We'd love to be able to trust people to make up their own minds about whether or not they are suitable, but with such a pretigious championship and certain people's attitudes, that's sadly not going to happen.
We may end up doing it on a case-by-case basis, but of course then we'll get the children complaining "OMG HE WAZ LET IN WAI CANNOT I RACE PL0X!111?!1!?!1!?1!?!/1" and so forth.
It's a difficult choice on this particular rule, I think all of us will have our own ideas within NDR itself, but any other "differentiating" rules from you would be good.
EDIT: But of course, I agree with the quoted about "giving the rest a chance". This series isn't meant for the aliens of this world
I agree with you J@tko. The rules was not perfect in my opinion, but it wasnt a bad solution to start with. I will say that the best opinion is doing it "case by case".
If a team has never driven in IGTC before (That a drive is in a team that havent been in IGTC/MoE), everyone in that team should be allowed to drive GTAL, but the teams that have teams in IGTC/MoE, we can have a maximum number of starts in IGTC/MoE or something (or that you review the drivers, one by one for example). Thats at least my opinion.
As there isnt easy for a team to "show what they got", to get up to MoE/IGTC, when they arent allowed to use a driver, because he has done 3-4 races for another team before. Endurance Racing is a team-sport, where every driver counts. And since this is a feeder series to IGTC/MoE, which is a team-based championship (and so is GTAL), I would like that most of the members can take part, as long as they havent done TOO many IGTC/MoE races/is way too fast, of course
Personally I see the IGTC as a feeder to MoE. How about maintain the absolutely no MoE experience rule and allow maybe 2 IGTC races over the last two seasons?
Remember we're not talking about excluding racers forever, they would maybe just have to sit out maybe one season until their IGTC starts became anulled.
Tis a tricky one for sure, but I'd differentiate between MoE and IGTC drives.
To make decisions on a "case by case" basis would lead to complete mayhem imo.
So i am not talking about whole team,i am talking about one driver(maybe some sort of rent-A-driver)
This stuff must be clearly xplained in rules,to avoid some special rules during season and other things.
I wont say that MoE drivers are faster than IGTC drivers, as they are almost the same
Im for that a driver/team can continue in GTAL the current season if they have got a space/started an IGTC race after the GTAL season has started. Thats a good experience for both the team/driver and in my opinion, they shouldnt loose the championship/the possibility to win it, because they got a chance in a good league. Its good experience for the team/driver.
Er... well if you look at what we did this season with GTAL, we had a pretty settled line up. We used GTAL to see how Howie would do in his first endurance type event, he did well so he stepped up to IGTC and we brought in another driver who will probably continue in GTAL next season to gain experience. We don't just stick people into IGTC, we plan to let them get experience in GTAL, just like we did this season... so yes, despite your "Don't mean to pick on you guys" if you are taking over admining this series, be aware of what teams who participate use GTAL to do, and don't talk tosh.
A common misconception people seem to have is that we can just pull drivers out of thin air who are able to drive endurance races. Utter tosh, our MoE/IGTC team is pretty settled and only about 9 drivers big. Using GTAL as we have done, we can get other drivers who might be useful to us in the future, and give them GTR Endurance experience, as well as giving them essential race experience, so they don't end up having a debut like I did at SO4 MoE that took me months to recover from.
Slap for Jack.
For what it's worth I think that it should still be no IGTC/MoE experience, unless there is exceptional circumstances, like a last minute stand in and they were rubbish. I could have done with doing GTAL when GTAL first started, but because we literarly had no drivers in MoE I had to drive and fail just to keep the team in MoE, and that cost me the chance to get experience on my own terms, and not worrying whether I was letting down the other two drivers. Things do happen...
I hope it would be a Amateur Leauge and not a waiting list for MoE/IGTC drivers they didn`t find a place to drive in this leauges.
I know`you work together with this leauges but pleas lat this leauge a Amateur leaug like the name say.