The online racing simulator
Schumacher to Mercedes?
(284 posts, started )
Quote from 5haz :Why does Alan insist to continue it?

If he didn't post the same crap over and over again, and regard his views as absolute fact, then perhaps Tristan would leave him alone?

Wait a second 5haz. In an earlier post I stated that my views are mere opinion. And that opinion is based on experiences from those that would know about this very subject.

I am not the one stating un-truths as fact.
#152 - CSF
Quote from BlueFlame :Brundle and Blundell? McLaren and Lotus? or Tyrell?

Ligier and Brabham 93 and 91.
Quote from Intrepid :Wait a second 5haz. In an earlier post I stated that my views are mere opinion. And that opinion is based on experiences from those that would know about this very subject.

Read: Taken from the views of others with little investigation or first hand experience.

Well you think its fact don't you, why else are you here, what are you trying to prove then?

To troll most likely.

Quote from Intrepid :I am not the one stating un-truths as fact.

I'd like to see you prove that karting is very similar to F1 using only established facts, figures and without an over reliance on the opinions of those who are probrably biased.
On topic

Ferrari must be freekin' seething. They've kept Schumacher in the F1 loop while he has been in 'retirement'. Got that free test last year!

For sure Alonso to Ferrari was an issue, but Schumacher is a savage. quality!
Changing the subject so suddenly are we? :mischievo
Quote from 5haz :I'd like to see you prove that karting is very similar to F1 using only established facts, figures and without an over reliance on the opinions of those who are probrably biased.

lol FFS!

So it started with

"You opinions are so stupid no one agrees with that"

to

"OK, the opinions, and experiences of people who know this stuff more than anyone might agree with you somewhat, but they must be biased"

to

"right I expect a full in depth investigation into the similarities of F1 and karting. You will be required to spend thousands upon thousands travelling the world to prove your point"

OK I will do. When do you want the report Sir? After that what next?
Quote from Intrepid :On topic

Ferrari must be freekin' seething. They've kept Schumacher in the F1 loop while he has been in 'retirement'. Got that free test last year!

For sure Alonso to Ferrari was an issue, but Schumacher is a savage. quality!

I guess that driving for Mercedes must have really appealed to him.

Maybe when you've been there and done that seven times already, there needs to be something different and/or special involved.
Quote from Intrepid :lol FFS!

So it started with

"You opinions are so stupid no one agrees with that"

to

"OK, the opinions, and experiences of people who know this stuff more than anyone might agree with you somewhat, but they must be biased"

to

"right I expect a full in depth investigation into the similarities of F1 and karting. You will be required to spend thousands upon thousands travelling the world to prove your point"

Nah your opinions are still stupid (I mean come on, you even admitted they're not even yours!) but thats just my opinion.

Quote from Intrepid :OK I will do. When do you want the report Sir? After that what next?

Well, to be honest I'd just prefer it if you shut the **** up.

Fine, just as long as you know that you can't expect me to leave me alone until you manage to do a proper argument using the thoughts in your own skull, not some crap that someone else has simply stuffed in there that you then pass off as the gospel truth.
Alan, again please just STFU. All we've heard from you over the past few weeks is Schumacher and Las Vegas, give it a f*cking rest!

My cousin started his career in karts at 15 and was absolutely crap, then went into Formula and kicked ass. To be competative in karting, you need to be in from a young age, have nothing else on your mind apart from karts and not drive anything else and a rich daddy, thats all they do.
Quote from 5haz :Nah your opinions are still stupid (I mean come on, you even admitted they're not even yours!) but thats just my opinion.



Well, to be honest I'd just prefer it if you shut the **** up.

Fine, just as long as you know that you can't expect me to leave me alone until you manage to do a proper argument using the thoughts in your own skull, not some crap that someone else has simply stuffed in there that you then pass off as the gospel truth.

The only way I could provide a proper arguement is by experiencing top level karting and top level F1. Now considering I don't have a TRILLION sitting in the bank it's not really gonna happen is it?

All we can rely upon is the experience and opinions of others who have experienced F1 and top flight karting. Now having spoken to these people and seen what they had to say I formed an opinion based on what they said because that's all we've got to go on.

I don't see you doing anything to back up your point of view.
Quote from pearcy_2k7 :

1. My cousin started his career in karts at 15 and was absolutely crap,

2. then went into Formula and kicked ass.

1. How do you know he was 'crap'? Results aren't everything!

2. What formula was it and what is his name?

You've made a sweeping generalisation there without providing any details.

Also why say STFU and then try to add to the debate only FUELING it?
Quote from Intrepid :The only way I could provide a proper arguement is by experiencing top level karting and top level F1. Now considering I don't have a TRILLION sitting in the bank it's not really gonna happen is it?

Shut up then. Or at least stop trying to claim victory all the time.

Quote from Intrepid :I don't see you doing anything to back up your point of view.

My own experince of racing cars in a field of smarmy recently graduated kartors with over inflated egos and pushy dads. The net result of them trying to adapt to cars was an embarrasing amount of red flags and a lot of bad press. (FYI, I had the lowest DNF rate of the entire field by the end of the season).
Quote from Intrepid :1. How do you know he was 'crap'? Results aren't everything!

2. What formula was it and what is his name?

You've made a sweeping generalisation there without providing any details.

Also why say STFU and then try to add to the debate only FUELING it?

Because he and his dad told me so.

NW Formula Ford champ in his first year, FPA and now porsche carrera cup which he got the sponsorship for.

Tom Bradshaw.

Theres your details.

You can talk, just don't talk stupid.
Quote from 5haz :My own experince of racing cars in a field of smarmy recently graduated kartors with over inflated egos and pushy dads. The net result of them trying to adapt to cars was an embarrasing amount of red flags and a lot of bad press. (FYI, I had the lowest DNF rate of the entire field by the end of the season).

I've seen the exact same thing happen the other way round as exclusively car drivers come into karting with the exact same attitude, causing red flags, crashing, getting huffy. I am not going to base my opinion on car drivers through that experience, I am not that stupid.

@Pearcy, while Bradshaw has done well has has avoided the traditional classes that the top talent karters move into with an eye on F1. F Renault/F3 etc... So to say he did crap in karts and then awesome in cars is slightly misleading. Because karting isn't just 'karting' and car racing isn't just 'car racing'. There are different levels and standards.


What we are discussing here is the highest levels of motorsport. NOT NATIONAL OR CLUB LEVEL.
Quote from Intrepid :I've seen the exact same thing happen the other way round as exclusively car drivers come into karting with the exact same attitude, causing red flags, crashing, getting huffy.

Yeah exactly, car racing and karting aren't the same are they?

Quote from Intrepid :What we are discussing here is the highest levels of motorsport. NOT NATIONAL OR CLUB LEVEL.

What has international motorsport got that makes it more like Karting than national motorsport?
Because he didn't have the budget, he kicked Alex Brundle and Jolyon Palmers ass, both sons of F1 drivers that are now racing in F2... And beat plenty of drivers that were good in karts and now he's in tintops and enjoying it so i doubt he'll go back to S-S now...

FPA is around 50k per year

F3 500k
Quote from 5haz :Yeah exactly, car racing and karting aren't the same are they?



What has international motorsport got that makes it more like Karting than national motorsport?

1. Your making sweeping generalisations about drivers you know NOTHING ABOUT. You don't know the history of the drivers you accuse of being all ego. They are just karters, nothing more nothing less. It's huge ignorance on your part.

My point is that I don't look at a few examples of car drivers coming into karting and being rubbish and then making a sweeping statement.

2. Your missing my point. Pearcy stated his cousin did crap in karts and then well in cars. But both were on a national level.

What we are discussing is the top levels of karting and the top levels of car racing.
Quote from pearcy_2k7 :Because he didn't have the budget, he kicked Alex Brundle and Jolyon Palmers ass, both sons of F1 drivers that are now racing in F2... And beat plenty of drivers that were good in karts and now he's in tintops and enjoying it so i doubt he'll go back to S-S now...

FPA is around 50k per year

F3 500k

Alex Brundle wasn't a top karter neither was Joylon Palmer. Brundle raced some club level stuff but nothing more. Club level junior rotax racing is a MILLION miles way from top flight senior KZ/KF racing. it's liek comparing MiniMoto and MotoGP. So

The best karters generally move into F BMW/F Renault/F3. Kids like Bianchi/Hulkenberg/Hamilton/ etc.... That's the level I am talking about. That's where this debate is. Not club level mishmashy stuff
Quote from Intrepid :Alex Brundle wasn't a top karter. He raced some club level stuff but nothing more. Club level rotax racing is a MILLION miles way from top flight KZ/KF racing. it's liek comparing MiniMoto and MotoGP

The best karters generally move into F BMW/F Renault/F3. Kids like Bianchi/Hulkenberg/Hamilton/ etc.... That's the level I am talking about.

lol i never said he was...

You think uk club karting is a million miles away from top flight karting, how far away is top flight karting from F1 then? Your ****ing deluded.
Quote from Intrepid :1. Your making sweeping generalisations about drivers you know NOTHING ABOUT. You don't know the history of the drivers you accuse of being all ego. They are just karters, nothing more nothing less. It's huge ignorance on your part.

I talked to other drivers who were ex-kartors, they were all terribly nice, until I started doing well.

And this was the majority, not one or two cases.
Quote from pearcy_2k7 :lol i never said he was...

You think uk club karting is a million miles away from top flight karting, how far away is top flight karting from F1 then? Your ****ing deluded.

I will quote Anthony Davidson ONCE A'FREAKIN'GAIN.

"Top Flight Kartig is the closest formula of motorsport to F1!"

So are you saying Anthony Davidson is deluded?
Quote from 5haz :I talked to other drivers who were ex-kartors, they were all terribly nice, until I started doing well.

And this was the majority, not one or two cases.

ex-karters? Who exactly and what level did they compete. And exactly what series did u race in?
Can I post my quote (paraphrase) of Ant saying virtually the opposite to Sniffpetrol again?

Schumacher to Mercedes?
(284 posts, started )
FGED GREDG RDFGDR GSFDG