Noononono.. CANNOT agree on that.. You only tried LFS with g25 I suppose.. Well, the game, in wich, I can feel the difference the most is RBR, the response time is so crucial, the ff is just ownage, and , it even wants a better pc spec, since the CPU just blows up with combo g25+rbr.. The shifter, is a cool thing, altough fragile on first look, it OWNS.. and then.. The pedals, I mean, they are not slipping away, in the first week, my left foot was kinda tired, and I was braking too little all the time in RBR. Then there is the FEEL of the wheel itself, I mean I look @ my old Formula Force Gp, and it seems, childishly small xD And the g25 ISNT expensive objectivly at all, I mean, its actually cheap, when you see what you get... Ok, so it does have its bugs, but mine is 100% fine, so it was the perfect choice, the momo I tried @ store, just felt, a level below g25....
G25 is NOT overrated, its just that good of a buy.