Toyota Corolla 1.4 vvti 2002-2005 Insurance Quote with a black box: £2658 (I would get this car but I prefer the 2005 models, since they have a new shape, but they are harder to find, plus they're slightly more expensive to buy)
Vw Golf 1.4 2002 Insurance Quote with a black box: £2869 I would get but the mileage is always high on golfs, plus I wouldn't like to keep the car for more than 3 years
Vw Polo 1.4 2001 (60bhp puts me off..) Insurance quote: Similar to the Golf, £2800. I would go for the Polo but 60 bhp puts me off, and I prefer the 2001 or 2007 Model with the facelift, but the 2007 models are harder to find.
Also, if I were to get the 2007 model, I would go for the 1.4 80bhp one, but again, they are hard to find, and go slightly above my budget.
Vauxhall Corsa C 1.4, Honda Civic 1.5 and a Citroen Saxo 1.1 upwards were all above £2800 to insure.
I haven't tried to insure the BMW since parts will be expensive if something goes wrong, and insurance will want something stupid like £5000.
So I guess it's a choice between a:
VW Polo 60bhp older model/80bhp newer but more expensive model
VW Golf 1.4 2002
Toyota Corolla 1.4 vvti 90bhp
OR just pay slightly more on insurance for a Corsa/Fiat Punto/Seat Ibiza 1.4 2002.
If anyone has anymore cars to suggest or what car I should go for on the ones that I have mentioned above, then please say.
See, I wouldn't be so picky about my first car, since most people only keep them and wait for their no claims bonus to kick in, and then buy a new car. However, I want to keep my first car for a lengthy amount of time, like I did with my first push bike.