The online racing simulator
Searching in All forums
(796 results)
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from DevilDare :Hehe. Can it get any worse?

Would love to hear Alonso's response on the radio.

I'm betting heavily there would at least be one article everyday of Alonso whining.

PS. I thought everyone who are a lap down would be able to pass the safety car and form up at the end of the queue? why are the Lotus and Virgins there between Lewis and Rosberg?
JCTK
S3 licensed
time for Alonso and Ferrari to cry even more!!!! =D

if he gave his place up to Kubica he wouldn't have got that penalty, but he chose not to, so shame!

even better for Alonso! Safety car is coming out now for the debris, the whole field will bunch up. And Alonso will drop right to the back!
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from DevilDare :Indeed. Alonso whines and cries about everything...

and Ferrari also whines and cries when things ain't working out for them too.

what a perfect match!
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from manneF1 :Why Alonso whines?

Kubica wasnt even close and he just cutted, should be penalized imo

because Alonso ALWAYS whines...
JCTK
S3 licensed
"great" strategy by McLaren. So that their two British World Champions can circulate together on the track for the photographers! XD

and I'll be surprised if Alonso can keep that place.
JCTK
S3 licensed
just about serves Vettel and RBR right.

it was a rational decision, but it wasn't an equitable decision, and they got punished with a punture.

PS. everyone behind Hamilton and ahead of the three new teams are circulating at pretty much the same pace!
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from DevilDare :They are not using them...

They took them off this morning. Its just a new floor.

which also meant they lost all of Friday to set the car up in its race specification.
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from PaulC2K :Distance to the pit is irrelevent, when they hit that pit button they're obviously aware the SC is out, not racing, and should be following SC conditions and your given a time in which to get there which will be based on how long it'd take travelling at something like 100kph. Everyone pitting will get that message. The only way there would be this pile-up you claim would happen is if they IGNORE the time they're given and they race to the pitlane at a higher average speed than they should do. Its that simple.

I think we will have to agree to disagree on this one.

No doubt drivers broke the rule, but was it necessary because the "spirit" of that regulation was to stop drivers driving pass accident zone at full speed. And they weren't driving pass the accident zone.

I think the FIA stewards agree to that to an extent, hence the very minor 5sec penalty.
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from MadCatX :There is somerhing pretty odd about this season when it comes to penalties. I dunno if it's just FIA having a mess in their regulations because of all the changes, but I guess that unless people actually stop watching races because of this obvious incompetence, we're gonna see more of it.

Every single punishment given in this race was just ridiculous. DT for passing SC in such short pitlane like the one in Valencia just isn't enough. 5 sec penalty? Who the hell has ever heard of that? Or is FIA allowed to make the rules as is goes? I hoped that Jean Todt will clean up after Mosley, but the sillyness of FIA has actually gotten to the whole new level

what's wrong with that?

yes, the drivers broke the rule, no doubt about it. But most of it was marginal and wasn't dangerous, and the FIA acknowledged that when deciding what penalties were appropriate.

What Alonso was so angry about was that if Lewis didn't brake but rather just went for it to pass the SC in the first place, he would have been able to do the same. But of course, he wouldn't say it, because he's crying about how Lewis passed the safety car.
JCTK
S3 licensed
it was all perfect timing for race control. XD

at the moment of Webber's crash the leaders are coming round the final hairpin, when they immediately call the SC to come out... well... it caused all sorts of chaos, and penalties... which made what was going to be a very boring race a lot more exciting. lol

and it keep the fans and the media busy. XD
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from Timo1992 :Agree he shouldnt complain about things like that which he also did himself

Alonso always cry when things don't go his way, and it seems like he've made an ideal match with Ferrari!

And as someone else said earlier, they're making the media and everybody busy, that no one forgot Alonso was useless during the race, which Kobayashi made easy meat of him, and Alonso was stuck behind a Toro Rosso for half the race, which somehow a Force India and a Sauber were able to pass!
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from Storm_Cloud :Just close the pits until the line has formed. If you are desperate to pit (for damage, puncture etc) then you may do so, but when the field is set for the restart you go to the back of the pack, so you fall behind all those who waited for the pits to open.

There's no issue with people running on fumes with the pits closed and if you close the pits then the only ones that can benefit are those near the bac, thus mixing up the order and promoting overtaking.

That, alas, will only happen once they stop letting the lunatics run the asylum by stopping letting teams write the rulebook.

that would also create all sort of mayhem. Because the teams are only allowed one set of pit crew for both cars. It'll end up being a mess with cars queuing, some cars trying to come out, some is driving down the lane normally, some just parked waiting for his turn to enter the pit.

The FIA isn't much better themselves in writing the rule book. The drive through penalty have been around for nearly 10 years already. But it's only this year they finally realised that, shall the equivalent of a drive through is handed after the race, there is no way that it's worth the same time as a 10sec stop go!
And because the FIA has no common sense, a 10sec stop go is worth 25sec, and a drive through somehow worths 20sec...
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from Storm_Cloud :If what Button said was correct then he should not have received any penalty, but they cannot all have been at pit entrance and it doesn't matter where they were in relation to the accident - the rules don't state it is a free for all once you're past the accident.

but what they are lacking is common sense and consistency in decisions, but I never expect the FIA stewards to have any of these, so.....

as I said earlier Nico Rosberg got away for it last year. This year, on his 25th bday, the FIA have managed to gift him one point thanks to these penalties.
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from hyntty :Interesting view. Passing the safety car or going too fast when it's deployed, surely they are a far more grave danger than for example exiting pits while the light is red. And still running the red light is punishable by disqualification.

Does not compute :/

1. passing the safety car was very marginal
2. it wasn't dangerous for "going too fast" in this scenario

the stewards have the power to issue harsher penalties shall they wish.
But to me, the 5sec penalty shouldn't be issued at all!
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from Storm_Cloud :Also, all the guys that drove too fast in safety car conditions get a 5 sec penalty. That doesn't feel right, as they're breaking a safety rule, rather than just a sporting code (like weaving, or passing the safety car).

Maybe there were too many to punish properly, which would've have been 24 seconds (equivalent to a drive through). It does set a precendent maybe and means that it may become a tactical penalty, the gain being greater than the punishment, which is bad for sport.

They were NOT driving too fast.
The race control would set a "time" which drivers must adhere to on that particular lap when the SC come out. In order to avoid drivers driving too fast into an accident zone.

BUT, all the drivers involved was AHEAD of the crash, some were VERY CLOSE to the pit entry, such as Button. What do you expect them to do? STOP AT THE PIT ENTRANCE to adhere to the time and possibly cause a massive pile up at the pitlane entrance?

Nico Rosberg had the same thing last year, most probably at this same track, and got away unpunished.
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from PhilS13 :I'm saying that in non-specific, hypothetical future race. If passing the SC gives a DT and you're the leader behind it just pass. Just shows how most teams and the FIA still are complete noobs when it comes to SC

I think the stewards have power to black flag a driver if the pass on SC was deliberate, there must be something in the rules to allow that to happen. And a whole host of other things could happen for "bringing the sport into disrepute".

But the one with Lewis was really very marginal, and damn that SLS is quick.
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from three_jump :That SC thing was stupid...

1) why didn't it come out before Vettel. As he would have got stuck behind Kobayashi as well...
2) to me it looked like Hamilton was unsure what to do braked first and then changed his mind
3) it needed 13 laps to come up with a penalty

That the penalty didn't change his position is something you can't blame Hamilton for. Kobayashi managed to keep the rest behind him so the gap was there.

The SC-Situation gets signaled at start finish so the leader should have to slow down that much that the SC can come out directly in front of him...

or on hindsight the SC should've waited till the pack have all passed.

race control have actually been pretty damn quick in scrambling out the SC after seeing Webber flying into the air, they must have expected something far worse as the medical car was right behind the safety car too, but at that point of time Vettel and co was most probably going into the final corner or at the start/finish straight already.

the SC was on the TV screen pretty damn quick immediately after Webber's crash.
Last edited by JCTK, .
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from PhilS13 :Sooo in F1 when you're the leader and behind the SC with the field bunched up. Just pass the SC and rejoin at the back of the pack. Spend 2-3 laps in traffic at the restart, get a DT, serve it, enjoy your free 50ish seconds gap.

50ish seconds gap? did you watched the same race as everyone else did?

Vettel "passed" the safety car too.

it is ok to pass the safety car as long as it is before that safety car line which was painted on the track. Lewis thought twice about that but by the time he tried out accelerate the safety car it was too late.
1). If Lewis didn't slam on the brakes he'd be ok.
2). F1 drivers can't see out the side of the car thanks to the HANS device, so Lewis couldn't see where the safety car is, because he was beside it.
JCTK
S3 licensed
something is seriously wrong. All the drivers investigated is being handed 5 seconds penalty, which isn't much. But it is just not justified.

But what the freak did FIA expect the drivers to do? Stop the freaken car just before the pit entry to ensure they comply with the time required? They were all ahead of the accident that caused the safety car, and some of them were pretty much at the pit entry when the SC board came out.

Now Alonso is 8th, Buemi ninth, Rosberg got a point, De la Rosa out of it. This is crazy!
It wasn't a scandal before these penalties, but it sure is now...
JCTK
S3 licensed
Alonso is now crying about the race being "manipulated".

But he was the one that benefited and won from a truly "manipulated" race, manipulated for his advantage, so he should either admit he shouldn't have won that Singapore GP too or just STFU.

He even said "Then with the safety car I would have finished where I finished in ninth, and Hamilton in eighth."
But he only finished 9th because of his inability to pass Buemi in a Toro Rosso. Which was something that a Force India and a BMW Sauber managed to do... lol
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from J@tko :Wasn't that Christian Horner?

Massive kudos to Kobayashi there - it's taken him 8 months but we've finally got some more of his awesome overtaking prowess

that was a Christian Horner look-alike
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from DevilDare :Kobayashi is freaking amazing.

The guy needs a good car. He isnt actually scared of trying to overtake.
Real showman.

Anyhow, nice one Vettel. And Mclaren. Hopefully Button doesnt get a harsh penalty.

Good race actually. Enjoyed it.

Kobayashi braked sooooooooo much later than Alonso, and somehow flicked it sideways into the corner and made that stick! AMAZING!!

Peter Sauber should forgive him for all his first lap crashes after today!
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from Bee :In hindsight, correct, it would seem un-racer like to slow down for an accident behind you. But if the SC is out, you don't run at race speed, simple.

the safety car was scramble out. They were at the end of the lap. Most of them could not have possibly slow down to satisfy that lap time unless they stop at the pitlane entry.

Stupid regulation and stupid safety car procedure.
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from Bee :Yeah but these are being investigated after the race so they can really only put on a time penalty or grid drop. Sucks, but rules are rules and if they we're gunning it after a huge crash like that, then penalties are deserved.

I think Jensen is setting fast laps now just in case of being handed a time penalty.

But I thought most of these cars were ahead of the accident when the safety car was "coming out". It would be a crap idea to ask them to come to a crawl just to satisfy that time.
JCTK
S3 licensed
Quote from Bee :It could be between a 20/30 sec time penalty or a grid drop for the next race. Either way, I reckon they'll be recieving penalties, more often than not when the FIA announce such a investigation, it's acted upon.

Kobayashi question: As far as I'm aware, they have to complete a lap on both compounds?

I think Martin Brundle commented before, only if the incident happened towards the end of the race (5 laps or something, couldn't remember), where the stewards wouldn't have time to think about it properly. Then the investigation after the race could be a time penalty.

And the safety car incident was very early in the race.

Not 100% sure through...

PS. De la Rosa (10th) is holding everyone else up nicely. At this rate Kobayashi should be able to come back out in 9th when he pit.
FGED GREDG RDFGDR GSFDG