He is kind of right, the sounds are far better on games like GTR, as are the graphics. The main thing that gets me though is the high nose on the formula cars, its a known bug, and one that has been in the game ages. I hate using the high nose as there is no feel in the car, but to be competitive you have to use it.
I really enjoy the tracks, and dont feel we need more as such, but a few other non turbo cars would be nice.
Also, Live For Speed really is an amazing game, but a bit more marketing would be good to draw a new crowd. It not only gives an advantage by producing more cash for the devs, but it also give more people for us to race with.